Skip to main content

Territorial Dispatch

Proposed Fish Creek Dams Raise Concerns

Nov 16, 2026 02:12PM ● By MPG Staff
South Yuba River Citizens League

Logo courtesy of South Yuba River Citizens League


NEVADA CITY, CA (MPG) - The South Yuba River Citizens League is raising concerns about a proposed 750-megawatt hydropower project on Fish Creek, a tributary of the South Yuba River, and is urging residents to submit public comments to federal regulators before Nov. 30.

RamaFlux Sierra PSH LLC has applied to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) for a preliminary permit to study the proposed pumped storage project near the town of Washington, east of Nevada City.

The proposal includes two dams and reservoirs, an underground powerhouse, construction roads and a 230-kilovolt transmission line through Sierra Nevada foothill forests.

According to the South Yuba River Citizens League (SYRCL), the proposed facility would have a generating capacity greater than all existing hydropower projects in the Yuba River watershed combined. Its proposed 750-megawatt capacity would also exceed the 710-megawatt capacity of Shasta Dam.

SYRCL questions whether Fish Creek, a stream approximately 1.5 miles long, could support a project of that size without affecting the surrounding watershed.

The organization identified several unanswered questions in the developer's application, including the proposed dimensions of the dams and reservoirs, the availability of water to fill them and the water rights needed to operate the facility.

SYRCL estimates that operating the project at its proposed capacity would require moving approximately 6,000 cubic feet of water per second through its turbines. An eight-hour operating period would circulate an estimated 1.3 billion gallons of water.

Although pumped storage facilities reuse water, SYRCL maintains that the proposed system raises questions about its water supply and potential effects on Fish Creek, Jefferson Creek and the South Yuba River.

The developer describes the facility as a "primarily closed-loop" system. SYRCL questions that designation because the proposal appears to involve constructing a dam on a flowing creek.

The organization also raised concerns about the developer's financing and the limited information available about potential investors and project partners.

According to the application, RamaFlux Sierra plans to spend $2.5 million studying the project, using funding from its owners and potential partnerships.

"SYRCL was born fighting dams on the South Yuba River," said Dr. Aaron Zettler-Mann, the organization's executive director. "The Fish Creek application raises serious concerns and leaves critical questions unanswered. Now is the time to raise our collective voice to speak up for this creek and this watershed before a project with significant unanswered questions gains regulatory momentum."

A preliminary permit would not authorize construction. Instead, it would give the developer priority to pursue a hydropower license while studying the project's feasibility.

The developer proposes completing hydrology, biological, engineering and water rights studies before submitting a final license application within two years.

SYRCL wants federal regulators to require sufficient environmental studies and provide opportunities for public review before the developer finalizes its plans.

The organization is also asking FERC to make completed studies available to the public.

Residents can submit comments through FERC's online system at ferconline.ferc.gov/QuickComment.aspx using docket number P-15429.

The deadline is 2 p.m. Pacific time Monday, Nov. 30.

SYRCL will host a public letter-writing event from 4 to 6 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, at its office, 313 Railroad Ave. in Nevada City. Staff will answer questions and assist residents with submitting comments.

A comment-writing toolkit is also available at YubaRiver.org.

SYRCL encourages residents to identify environmental, technical and community concerns, along with information they believe federal regulators should consider when evaluating the proposal.

The organization has also asked residents to email copies of their comments to [email protected].

For additional information, contact SYRCL at [email protected].